Under Construction

BLOG

10 Oct 2023

Can Singapore unlock Africa’s green hydrogen potential?

Tags
Green Hydrogen, Energy Transition
Author
Professor Michaël Tanchum,
Green Hydrogen

Africa has an estimated[1] potential to produce US$1.06 trillion worth of green hydrogen by 2035. Viewed as a premier energy carrier that will facilitate the global transition to renewable energy sources, European and Asian firms are turning their attention to developing Africa’s enormous green hydrogen potential.  While the North African nations of Morocco and Egypt have emerged as green hydrogen leaders, the Sahelian nation of Mauritania is a key to unlocking hydrogen potential of sub-Saharan Africa (SSA).  With several international consortia competing to develop Mauritania’s green hydrogen production infrastructure, the consortium led by British energy firm Chariot has developed a unique edge through its acquisition of Singaporean water desalination technology.

The Global Rush for Green Hydrogen and Green Ammonia

An energy carrier produced from renewable energy sources, green hydrogen can be used directly as a fuel, an input for manufacturing processes (such as ‘green steel’ production) or as an energy storage and transportation system. While all three uses are critical for climate-friendly commerce and industry, it is particularly the function as a storage system for renewable power that makes green hydrogen vital to energy transition. The electricity produced by solar and wind power is intermittent and variable, depending on hours of daylight or wind availability. Green hydrogen stands as an alternative technology to utility scale batteries – which require toxic and difficult to obtain minerals – for storing energy produced from renewable sources and then deploying on demand.

Different from natural gas-derived hydrogen produced in a process that releases considerable volumes of CO2 into the atmosphere (and therefore called “gray” hydrogen), green hydrogen is produced by using electricity generated from renewable sources to split water into its hydrogen and oxygen components, creating a versatile, carbon-free (hence, “green”) energy carrier.  Reversing the electrolysis process in a fuel cell by recombining green hydrogen and oxygen back into water generates electric current, providing on-demand, climate-smart power.  The further advantage of green hydrogen is that the most cost-effective way to store and transport green hydrogen is in the form of its derivative green ammonia. Since ammonia is one of the basic inputs for fertilizer manufacturing – currently accounting for about 70%[2] of global ammonia consumption – there is already offtake demand for green ammonia, which can easily use existing ammonia storage and transportation infrastructure.

The pressing need for green ammonia to make agriculture sustainable and resilient against natural gas price shocks is also driving the rush to develop green hydrogen. While the European nations of the Netherlands, Germany, France, Spain, and Italy are consistently among the world’s top ten food exporters[3], the poor quality of their soils make them heavily reliant on synthetic fertilizers[4] to maintain their high levels of agricultural production. On the whole, 50% of European agriculture[5] is dependent on synthetic fertilizers. With natural gas accounting for at least 80% of the variable cost[6] of fertilizer through the use of conventional gray ammonia as a primary input, the commercial viability of European agriculture is tied to affordable supplies of natural gas.

The 400% spike in European natural gas prices in 2021 due to Covid-19 induced supply shocks saw the cost of producing ammonia rise almost ten-fold to US$1,000 per ton leading to a commensurate price rise in synthetic fertilisers. The skyrocketing of gas prices due to the Russia-Ukraine war forced European fertiliser giant Yara to shutter two-thirds of its ammonia production[7], including its plants in France and Italy. A number of European plants making ammonia and more complex fertilisers were forced to shut down last year (2022) due to high natural gas, from Spain’s Fertiberia[8] to Germany’s BASF.[9] The United Kingdom similarly witnessed the closing[10] of its largest fertilizer plant operated by the U.S. firm, CF Industries.

European firms from the leading food exporting countries have been at the forefront driving the development of green hydrogen and green ammonia production in North Africa - particularly in Morocco[11] and Egypt[12], which also have their own significant fertilizer industries. For its part, Morocco’s state-owned fertilizer manufacturing giant OCP (Office Chérifien des Phosphates) – the world’s fourth largest fertilizer exporter – announced[13] in July 2023 that it would construct its own US$7 billion green ammonia plant in the Kingdom.  The plant is intended to help the company replace its annual import of US$2bn worth of gray ammonia with domestically produced green ammonia.

Mauritania: A Rising Star in Green Hydrogen

Neighbouring Mauritania is similarly awash with solar energy resources.  Three-quarters of the country is covered[14] by the Sahara Desert whose direct normal irradiation (DNI) levels reach or exceed 2,200 kWh/m2.[15] While possessing solar and wind energy resources at the level of North Africa green hydrogen leaders Morocco and Egypt, Mauritania’s population is 7 times smaller than the former and 20 times smaller than the latter. Sparsely inhabited with a population of about 5 million, Mauritania can more easily serve export markets while using the same renewable energy infrastructure to provide for the needs of its own population. 

The region surrounding the northern coastal city of Nouadhibou, slated to be a center of green hydrogen production receives a DNI of about 2,074 kWh/m2.[16] The region also possesses rich wind energy resources, with onshore wind speeds[17] of 7 meters per second and even faster speeds offshore.  The region already hosts a 30MW[18] wind power generation complex. The country’s capital Nouakchott, on the southern portion of Mauritania’s coast, receives a DNI of about 1,600 kWh/m2.[19] Mauritania’s total wind energy resources are estimated[20] to be 175 GW.  Of the five Sahel nations, Mauritania is the only one with a coastline and so can easily provide offtake for export markets. Mauritania’s coast is also an essential factor for green hydrogen production itself, the process requires[21] 9 kilograms of water for every kilogram of hydrogen produced. Like water-depleted Morocco and Egypt, Mauritania’s green hydrogen production will have to rely on freshwater provided by dedicated renewable energy-powered seawater desalination plants.

Despite becoming natural gas player with through the joint development with Senegal of their shared offshore reserves, Mauritania has adopted a national energy transition strategy[22] to increase renewable energy sources to 60% of its energy supply mix by 2030.  Mauritania seeks to use its solar and wind energy resources to become a major green hydrogen/green ammonia exporter.  As Mauritanian Minister of Petroleum, Energy, and Mines Abdessalem Ould Mohamed Saleh declared, “Our country is determined to play a leading position on the global map of the green hydrogen economy in the coming decades.”

Mauritania has not been lacking for international partners to help Nouakchott attain its green hydrogen objectives. An early entrant to Mauritania’s green hydrogen sector is Australia’s CWP, which has been implementing its 2021 MOU with government of Mauritania to develop a US$40bn[23] green hydrogen/green ammonia complex known as the AMAN project. According to the subsequent May 2022 framework agreement[24],  the AMAN project will include an installed capacity of 30 GW with 18 GW from wind power and 12GW from solar. Located in Mauritania’s northern port of Nouadhibou and the neighboring Inchiri region, the AMAN project is expected[25] to produce annually 1.7 million tons of green hydrogen or 10 million tons of green ammonia for local use and export. Massive in scale, AMAN’s slated green ammonia output is equivalent to about five times the current production input requirements[26] of Moroccan fertiliser manufacturing sector.

CWP’s efforts are facing competition in Mauritania’s green hydrogen market from a consortium of companies from Germany, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), and Egypt. Firms from Germany and the UAE have taken leading roles in partnering[27] with Cairo to develop the green hydrogen and green ammonia sectors in Egypt, already among the world’s top ten ammonia exporters. Emirati-owned green ammonia production in Egypt will service the output of Fertiglobe[28], the world’s largest export-focused fertiliser platform jointly owned by the Emirates’ Abu Dhabi National Oil Company and the Netherlands’ fertiliser producer OCI NV.  In March 2023, German development and investment firm Conjuncta in cooperation with the Emirati-Egyptian joint venture Infinity Power Holding signed an initial agreement with Mauritania to develop a US$34bn[29] green hydrogen complex. The multiphase project will ultimately have an electrolyzer capacity 10 GW and produce 8 million ton of green hydrogen or its derivative equivalent. Infinity Power, composed of Egypt’s Infinity company and the Emirates’s renewable energy giant MASDAR are already engaged in the development of a 2 GW green hydrogen facility[30] in Egypt.  The phase one development of the Mauritania complex, located northeast of the capital Nouakchott, will consist of a 400 MW facility is expected to be operational in 2028.[31]

Against the background of these massive infrastructure projects, the British energy firm Chariot is leading a consortium to develop yet another green hydrogen/green ammonia project.  In September 2021, Chariot signed an MOU[32] with the Mauritanian government to advance the development “Project Nour”, a green hydrogen facility of up to 10 GW, using solar and wind resources in the Nouadhibou region. On the occasion of the signing of the agreement, energy minister Saleh reiterated Mauritania’s ambitions to be a central player in the global green hydrogen economy.  “We have the potential, and desire,” Minister Saleh declared[33],  “to be a world leader in the field of hydrogen production from renewable energy sources."

Mauritania’s green hydrogen export ambitions took one step closer to realization in April 2022, when Chariot signed an MOU[34] with the Port of Rotterdam in the Netherlands for the import of up to 600,000 tons of green hydrogen per year produced by Project Nour. Chariot regards[35] as the Rotterdam agreement as “a first step in establishing supply chains to enable the sale of green hydrogen and its derivative products (notably ammonia) into Europe.”  Following the announcement, the Dutch state-owned natural gas transmission network operator Gasunie, the Netherlands-headquartered bulk handling giant HES International, and the Netherlands’ global leader in tank storage Vopak formed a consortium for the construction of a new green ammonia import terminal[36] in Rotterdam’s Maasvlakte port, which is expected to be operational by 2026.  

In the following month, Chariot completed Project Nour’s pre-feasibility study[37] in May 2022 and signed[38] a framework agreement with the Mauritania government for the next development phases.  With potential export offtake mechanism in place and the pre-feasibility study completed, Chariot’s position in the race to develop Mauritania’s green hydrogen sector was advanced in September 2022 when Total Eren, now a wholly-owned subsidiary[39] of French energy giant TotalEnergies, entered into a 50-50 partnership[40] for the development of the Nour project, bringing its considerable experience and expertise in the renewable energy sector.

Singapore Water Tech Edge

In 2023, Chariot developed a further edge over its rivals in Mauritania’s green hydrogen sector through the acquisition of a water desalination technology pioneered in Singapore. On 30 January 2023, Chariot announced its purchase of Singapore-headquartered ENEO Water PTE, which focuses on water treatment for arid regions.  Green hydrogen production at Chariot’s Project Nour complex will use fresh water[41] from a coastal desalination plant powered by solar and wind energy, raising the challenge for the company to provide sufficient freshwater as a production input while contributing to the politically important task of making sure Mauritania’s renewable energy is also used to provide sufficient freshwater to the its population. ENEO’s technology will help Chariot meet the challenge. The company’s core specialisation[42] involves the solar-powered reverse osmosis desalination systems that are modular and scalable, making ENEO’s systems easily deployable in less accessible parts of Africa. One ENEO system has already been deployed[43] in a brackish water treatment project in Djibouti powered by the 60 MW Ghoubet wind farm. Chariot views[44] ENEO’s Djibouti project as a proof-of-concept for coupling renewable energy and desalination to achieve sustainable water management. 

Concerned to balance the water requirements for green hydrogen production with the needs local communities, Chariot intends[45] to originate, invest in, and own decentralised water supply projects, where the water is produced through renewable energy and can be sold to off takers under long-term agreements. Noting that “Water is a precious commodity with cleanliness, scarcity and sustainability of supply becoming growing themes throughout Africa,” Chariot executive Benoit Garrivier observed[46] that the ENEO “technology we use is both modular and scalable we look forward to expanding this offering, in line with our mission of creating value whilst delivering a range of positive impacts.” The executive noted ENEO’s technology was a “strong strategic fit” for Chariot’s green hydrogen production as well as its stated aim to also provide local communities with affordable water access, in line with its commitment to socially responsible development.

Africa-Asia Green Hydrogen Cooperation on the Horizon

The regions of Africa that enjoy extraordinary green hydrogen potential, simultaneously suffer from acute water stress, witnessing increasing periods of drought driven by climate change. Approaches to developing green hydrogen production like that being carried out by Chariot in Mauritania – using climate-smart, Singaporean desalination technology to provide freshwater supplies for both the green hydrogen industry and the local population – will need to be replicated across Africa. In August 2023, Chariot signed an agreement[47] with Morocco’s Mohamed IV Polytechnic University to build a pilot green hydrogen/green ammonia as a proof-of-concept pilot project intended for future large-scale production.

Although European firms have been at the forefront of the effort to develop Africa’s green hydrogen potential, an Africa-Asia green hydrogen future seems to be on the horizon, as the coal-burning regions of Asia move toward ‘co-firing’, using both ammonia and coal as fuel in hitherto coal-fired power plants. Japan’s JERA, the nation's largest power generation company, will be conducting a test run[48] of co-firing at its coal plant in Aichi, employing a fuel mix of 20 per cent ammonia and 80 per cent coal. JERA aims to move the fuel mix to 50-50 during the 2030s and then phase out coal entirely in favor of ammonia by the 2050s. Japan also eyes exporting the technology across Asia with Mitsubishi Heavy Industries developing[49] boilers and gas turbines for ammonia co-firing. 

To achieve the desired carbon-neutral outcome, Japan and other Asia nations using co-firing as an intermediate step will need to import African-produced green ammonia. Japan is also endeavoring to develop[50] a prototype 100% ammonia-fired powerplant by 2030. In parallel, Japanese energy diplomacy has been seeking to develop a wider East Asian fuel ammonia ecosystem. On 10 January 2022, Japan signed a Memorandum of Cooperation[51] (MOC) Indonesia, 62.5%[52] of whose power is generated from burning coal, to cooperate in the development of fuel ammonia technology. Two days later, Japan signed an MOC[53] with Singapore to establish ammonia supply chains to “serve both Japan and Singapore markets, and broader demand in Asia-Pacific markets,” with the expressed objective to “explore Singapore’s potential to become a regional trading hub for hydrogen and hydrogen-based energy carriers.” On 13 January 2022, Japan also signed an MOC[54] with Thailand to assist in Thailand’s decarbonization efforts, including the use of fuel ammonia.

All three of Japan’s MOCs with its Southeast Asian partners envision cooperation on fuel ammonia and other climate-smart technologies as the means to achieve their respective climate commitments under the Paris agreement.  So the path to a low carbon future for Asia goes is likely to go through Africa. With Africa-to-Asia green ammonia supply chains looming on the horizon, Asian companies like Singapore’s ENEO have a big part to play in unlocking Africa’s green hydrogen potential.

Author

This blog is authored by Professor Michaël Tanchum,  a research fellow with NTU-SBF CAS, a non-resident fellow with the Middle East Institute's Economics and Energy Program and teaches at Universidad de Navarra. You can follow him on Twitter @michaeltanchum. The author would like to thank Regan Marina Thomas and Rocco Schwerfel for their research assistance. The piece is originally published on Nanyang Technology University's website.

 

References

[1] https://renewafrica.biz/green-hydrogen/study-estimates-africas-green-hydrogen-potential-at-us1-trillion-by-2035/ 

[2] https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/6ee41bb9-8e81-4b64-8701-2acc064ff6e4/AmmoniaTechnologyRoadmap.pdf

[3] https://oec.world/en/profile/hs/foodstuffs 

[4] https://www.iai.it/en/pubblicazioni/food-energy-nexus-and-italy-morocco-cooperation 

[5] https://www.euractiv.com/section/agriculture-food/news/europe-searches-for-alternatives-in-fertiliser-supply-battle/ 

[6] https://www.foodbusinessnews.net/articles/20163-high-fertilizer-prices-tight-supplies-may-adversely-affect-2022-acreage 

[7] https://www.yara.com/corporate-releases/yara-implements-further-production-curtailments-in-europe/ 

[8] https://www.canalsur.es/noticias/andalucia/la-crisis-energetica-obliga-a-fertiberia-a-parar-su-planta-de-palos-de-la-frontera/1853033.html 

[9] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/basf-considers-more-ammonia-production-cuts-gas-supply-crunch-sources-2022-07-27/ 

[10] https://www.ft.com/content/736739a3-780d-4480-a398-37ce1edf99e8 

[11] https://www.iai.it/en/pubblicazioni/food-energy-nexus-and-italy-morocco-cooperation 

[12] https://www.mei.edu/publications/egypts-synergy-between-natural-gas-and-green-energy-transition-cairos-advances-lng-and 

[13] https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/climate-energy/moroccos-ocp-plans-7-mln-green-ammonia-plant-avert-supply-problems-2023-06-20/ 

[14] https://tech-action.unepccc.org/country/mauritania/ 

[15] https://globalsolaratlas.info/download/mauritania 

[16] ibid

[17] https://mauritaniaenergy.com/?page_id=1593 

[18] ibid 

[19] https://globalsolaratlas.info/download/mauritania

[20] https://mauritaniaenergy.com/?page_id=1593 

[21] https://www.mei.edu/publications/egypts-synergy-between-natural-gas-and-green-energy-transition-cairos-advances-lng-and

[22] https://eiti.org/blog-post/road-mauritanias-natural-gas-and-green-hydrogen-future#:~:text=Demand%20for%20green%20hydrogen%20is,to%20decarbonise%20its%20mining%20sector 

[23] https://gh2.org/countries/mauritania#:~:text=Project%20Aman%3A%20The%20Government%20of,the%20green%20hydrogen%20production%20facility

[24] https://www.cwp.global/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Mauritania-and-CWP-sign-a-framework-agreement-for-the-AMAN-project.pdf 

[25] ibid 

[26] https://www.mei.edu/publications/moroccos-new-challenges-gatekeeper-worlds-food-supply-geopolitics-economics-and 

[27] https://www.ispionline.it/en/publication/energy-politics-mena-region-hydrocarbons-renewables-36797 

[28] https://www.thenationalnews.com/weekend/2022/05/06/the-uaes-food-security-strategy-has-made-it-a-global-market-player/ 

[29] https://www.thenationalnews.com/business/2023/03/09/infinity-power-and-conjuncta-to-develop-green-hydrogen-project-in-mauritania/ 

[30] https://weareiph.com/under-development 

[31] https://hydrogen-central.com/infinity-power-conjuncta-develop-green-hydrogen-project-mauritania/ 

[32] https://chariotenergygroup.com/app/uploads/2021/10/Green-Hydrogen-Project_Chariot-Limited.pdf 

[33] ibid

[34] https://energycapitalpower.com/chariots-3-5-billion-mauritania-based-green-hydrogen-project-secures-european-export-route/ 

[35] https://chariotenergygroup.com/operations/green-hydrogen/#:~:text=Chariot%20is%20working%20in%20partnership,to%20enable%20the%20sale%20of 

[36] https://energycapitalpower.com/chariots-3-5-billion-mauritania-based-green-hydrogen-project-secures-european-export-route/ 

[37] https://chariotenergygroup.com/operations/green-hydrogen/#:~:text=Chariot%20is%20working%20in%20partnership,to%20enable%20the%20sale%20of 

[38] ibid

[39] https://www.agenceecofin.com/energies-renouvelables/2607-110644-energies-renouvelables-apres-5-annees-d-alliance-strategique-totalenergies-acquiert-entierement-total-eren 

[40] https://www.total-eren.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Green-Hydrogen-Partnering_06.09.22_EN_final_v2_clean.pdf 

[41] https://energycapitalpower.com/chariots-3-5-billion-mauritania-based-green-hydrogen-project-secures-european-export-route/ 

[42] https://www.upstreamonline.com/energy-transition/chariot-acquisition-of-singapore-player-boosts-huge-mauritania-green-hydrogen-project/2-1-1396351?zephr_sso_ott=MKVyBv 

[43] https://www.afrik21.africa/en/africa-chariot-invests-in-water-desalination-with-the-acquisition-of-eneo/ 

[44] https://chariotenergygroup.com/app/uploads/2023/01/2023.01.30-ENEO-release-FINAL.pdf 

[45] ibid

[46] ibid

[47] https://chariotenergygroup.com/app/uploads/2023/08/Green-H2-Morocco-partnership-agreement-02.08.23-FINAL.pdf 

[48] https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Business-Spotlight/Japan-warms-to-disputed-coal-power-technology-under-West-s-icy-stare 

[49] ibid

[50] https://www.jogmec.go.jp/content/300381295.pdf 

[51] https://www.meti.go.jp/press/2021/01/20220113003/20220113003-1.pdf 

[52] https://www.statista.com/statistics/993362/indonesia-energy-mix-for-power-generation-by-source/ 

[53] https://www.meti.go.jp/press/2021/01/20220113003/20220113003-3.pdf

[54] ibid

Add New Comment